Smarter Grading: Choosing the Right Method for Every Task

With more classrooms adopting AI tools like Speakable, understanding how to apply its grading options effectively can help you give students meaningful feedback without adding to your workload. Each method is designed for different types of language tasks. Here's a simple guide to help you choose the best one for your lesson.

‍

📝 Short Answer (No Grading Method)

Based on an optionally added correct answer. Best for drills and recall practice where the teacher defines exact correctness rules. Works well for translations, conjugations, and fill-in-the-blank activities but does not provide feedback on language complexity.

Do Use For:

1. Fill-in-the-blank: “Yo ___ (hablar) español.”
2. Conjugation drills: “Conjugate ‘comer’ in the present tense.”
3. Simple translations: “Translate ‘library’ into French.”

Don’t Use For:

1. Evaluating fluency (“Tell me about your weekend.”)
2. Style or complexity (“Describe your favourite movie in detail.”)
3. Multi-dimensional grading (“Give a 1-minute presentation.”)

‍

✔️ Pass-Fail (Most Versatile)

A custom prompt that requires the student to meet all requirements. Teachers set the criteria for what counts as correct, making it useful for a wide range of scenarios—from simple checks to open-ended responses. Offers feedback on language use without the complexity of rubrics.

Do Use For:

1. Flexible custom prompts that check correctness or language use with requirements (“Describe 3 things you did over the weekend in the preterit tense.”)
2. Short or medium-length responses where usage feedback is desired
3. Situations where teachers want grading to feel more like a simplified rubric

Don’t Use For:

1. Yes/No or one-word answers (“Is the sky blue?”)
2. Overly simple vocabulary checks (“Translate ‘cat’ into Spanish.”)
3. Tasks requiring detailed, multi-dimensional feedback (use Rubric-Based instead)

Note: Pass-Fail is versatile and adapts well to many contexts from simple checks to more complex prompts.

‍

📊 Standards-Based (Reach a Target Level)

Instead of correctness, grading focuses on whether the response demonstrates enough complexity, fluency, and control to match a chosen ACTFL or WIDA standard. This method is best for encouraging growth in proficiency.

Do Use For:

1. Longer, more complex prompts (“Describe your weekend in Spanish. Use the preterit tense.”)
2. Growth tracking (“Narrate a past event at ACTFL Intermediate-Mid.”)
3. Sentence variety and fluency (“Talk about your hobbies in 5 different sentences.”)

Don’t Use For:

1. Correctness checks (“Translate ‘cat.’”)
2. One expected answer (“What is ‘blue’ in French?”)
3. Simple recall drills (“List days of the week.”)

Warning: Standards-Based grading measures proficiency, not correctness. A correct answer may still fall short if it lacks the required complexity.

‍

📑 Rubric-Based

Uses custom rubrics for multi-dimensional grading with partial credit. Teachers can create categories like grammar, vocabulary, organisation, or creativity. Best for longer and more complex responses where detailed feedback is needed.

Do Use For:

1. Extended writing (“Write a 100-word essay about your favourite holiday.”)
2. Presentations (“Give a 2-minute talk about your family.”)
3. Multi-criteria tasks (“Debate a topic in Spanish using at least 3 arguments.”)

Don’t Use For:

1. Short translations (“Translate ‘school’ into German.”)
2. Simple grammar drills (“Conjugate ‘ser.’”)
3. Quick checks (“Name a colour in Spanish.”)

‍

‍

Pro Tip:
Think about what you want to measure: accuracy, fluency, growth, or structure. Choose the grading method that fits. Speakable lets you shape the feedback to match your lesson’s goal.

Next time you create an activity, try choosing a different grading method and see how it changes the type of feedback your students receive.

Request a Demo Here